'The Bachelor' Contestant Victoria Larson Was Arrested in 2012

Victoria Larson‘s past is resurfacing.

E! News revealed on Thursday (January 21) that The Bachelor constestant was arrested for shoplifting in 2012.

The police report filed after the incident says Victoria was caught on camera stealing $250 worth of items from a grocery store.

According to E! News, “A witness saw her place items in a reusable shopping bag inside her shopping cart, but when she went to pay at self-checkout, she didn’t scan the items in the bag, only the other items in her cart.”

Police were called to the scene and arrested Victoria, who later pleaded no contest to charges of petit theft.

While the 28-year old reality star has not addressed the incident directly, she seemed to subtly reference the arrest in an Instagram posted Friday (January 22). She wrote in the caption, “Every saint has a past & every sinner has a future. John 8: 7.”

Bachelor fans think they may have figured out who the winner of Matt James‘ season is – find out who the rumored winner is!